Inside Iowa’s Political Sweat Session: The MAGA-MAHA Clash That’s Heating Up the Heartland!

Inside Iowa’s Political Sweat Session: The MAGA-MAHA Clash That’s Heating Up the Heartland!

Imagine sipping your morning water only to wonder if that clear, refreshing gulp might just be a cocktail of chemicals instead. That’s the grim reality unfolding in Iowa, where rivers, streams, and creeks have been transformed into amateur chemistry labs courtesy of agribusiness practices gone awry. It’s not just an environmental headache—cancer rates in the state are climbing steeply, linked to nitrates and the infamous weedkiller Roundup. And guess what? Politics is knotted up in the mess too, with deep divisions within the GOP, a curious defense of these toxins from high up, and a Democratic candidate daring to challenge the status quo by asking: what has controlling nature really done for us? If you ever thought drinking water was simple, Iowa’s crisis might just turn your thinking upside down — and raise a powerful question about what we’re really voting for when ballots go in. For the full unfiltered dive, dive in here: LEARN MORE.

Estimated read time3 min read

Politico did a fine deep dive, you should pardon the expression, into the severe water crisis afflicting Iowa due to how the state’s agribusiness is turning creeks and streams and rivers into chemistry sets. It’s some seriously ugly stuff.

In recent years, Iowa’s cancer rate has climbed significantly above the U.S. average. It now stands as the nation’s second highest, and Iowa is one of only three states where the rate is rising. The situation has put a spotlight on nitrates, which are linked to a growing body of science to kidney, brain and ovarian cancer. Nitrates are a key component in the deluge of chemical pesticides and fertilizers used by the state’s farmers, some of which washes off farm fields and into waterways. A second culprit is glyphosate, the active ingredient in Roundup, the world’s most common weedkiller, which the International Agency for Research on Cancer declared “probably carcinogenic” in 2015, an assessment rejected by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.

The Trump administration is all in on Roundup, so much so that it has caused an acrimonious split between MAGA and MAHA. From Grist:

MAHA’s disenchantment with the Trump administration has much to do with its open support of Bayer, the manufacturer of the popular pesticide Roundup, which just won a Supreme Court case over the claim that the company failed to adequately warn users about the cancer risk of its weedkiller. First, the administration urged the Supreme Court to take up the case. Then, in February, the president signed an executive order that classified glyphosate-based herbicides like Roundup key to national security and called for increased domestic production of the chemical. In March, it was reported that top officials at the Environmental Protection Agency met with Bayer’s CEO to discuss “litigation” issues. The following month, the administration sent a lawyer to argue on behalf of the chemical company in a Supreme Court hearing.

Politico being Politico, the piece leans heavily on the effect the water—and disease—crisis is having on the state’s politics and how the MAGA-MAHA brouhaha will resolve itself before the midterms. But the star of the piece is one Chris Jones, the Democratic candidate for agriculture secretary.

The farm he is visiting raises a variety of vegetables in unruly, green gardens: peppers, sweet corn, green beans, potatoes and collards. Though the farmer grows soybeans on some of the property to make ends meet, other fields have been allowed to return to marshy wetland. It’s a sharp contrast to the corn and soybean fields that carpet most of Iowa’s farmland, geometrically arrayed and stretching from fence row to fence row. Jones admits this farm looks a bit “chaotic,” especially when compared to one of its huge, conventional counterparts. Those farms, Jones says, are an attempt to control nature, and “what has controlling nature here done for us?” He turns back to the pond. “It’s polluted all our water. It’s really destroyed a lot of Iowa.”

“Cancer doesn’t care what party you belong to,” Jones said. “Republicans don’t like drinking poisonous water any more than Democrats do.”

Jones has been gifted with an opponent supremely unqualified to speak about the water crisis.

His Republican opponent is the incumbent secretary of agriculture, Mike Naig, who can’t really run on water. That’s because, of all things, he actually worked as the manager of state and local government affairs in Iowa for Monsanto, the maker of the widely used herbicide Roundup, which is now owned by Bayer. Naig puts a sunny spin on the water problem, doubling down on the state’s voluntary approach to cajoling farmers to pollute less while insisting that things are getting better—a claim that isn’t backed by data collected from waterways.

So maybe this will be enough for the people in Iowa to vote in their actual self-interest instead of marching to the culture-war cowbells. Back in 2018, after the president had dropped his first bunch of tariffs, which murdered Iowa’s soybean farmers, I went to the state GOP convention. There were four or five people running for agriculture, and every one of them went out off their way to declare themselves rigidly against abortion. None of them talked about tariffs, not even the candidate who’d once been a soybean lobbyist. Maybe Roundup will be enough.

Post Comment

WIN $500 OF SHOPPING!

    This will close in 0 seconds