The Shocking Truth Behind This Weekend’s National Scandal That Could Change Everything You Thought You Knew

The Shocking Truth Behind This Weekend’s National Scandal That Could Change Everything You Thought You Knew

What’s more surprising than a headline-grabbing resignation these days? Well, it’s seeing the top dog at National Savings & Investments (NS&I) step down over what’s basically an administrative mess involving £476 million trapped in Premium Bonds. It’s the kind of blunder that makes you wonder—how did a government-backed institution, trusted by more than 24 million customers, let this slip through the cracks? And yet, despite the millions affected and the heartache of families stuck waiting years to reclaim their money, the root cause seems to be less about malicious intent and more about systemic failure. Still, when you’re backed 100% by the government, the stakes—and standards—are sky-high. So, what does this say about trust, responsibility, and just how unforgiving the spotlight can be for those at the helm? If you’ve ever vouched for “safe as houses” investments like NS&I, this week’s shake-up offers plenty to chew on. LEARN MORE

What caught my eye this week.

Considering the high hurdle that politicians and business leaders have set themselves for something to be considered a sacking offence, I was surprised to see the boss of National Savings & Investments (NS&I) resign this week.

Of course, the NS&I FUBAR was a rough experience for the 37,500 people affected. NS&I’s mistakes saw bereaved families facing delays accessing their relatives’ Premium Bonds with a total value of up to £476m.

To give just one example from a BBC report:

Tracy McGuire-Brown from Newbury in Berkshire […] took six years to claim £2,000 in premium bonds her late father had left in his will.

The 61-year-old former care home manager says she “cannot describe how upsetting and frustrating” it was to deal with NS&I, and that she had to send in her father’s will and other original documents at her own expense.

“It was the most awful, awful experience,” she says.

No doubt – and not what anyone wants to deal with in the wake of the death of a loved one.

However, NS&I has more than 24 million customers holding £240bn with the institution, so the number affected is relatively small. According to Which the problems were caused by administrative failures – bad, certainly, but not malicious. The long delay between problems emerging and NS&I coming clean is problematic, but again the scale of the operation mitigates this to some extent.

With all that said – and, again, not to make light of having to fight to get your own money back – I think the real reason boss Dax Harkins had to go was because NS&I is held to a higher standard than a typical High Street bank, on the basis of its 100% government backing.

Trust buster

I’ve often recommended NS&I savings or Premium Bonds to fretful – but essentially financially uninterested – friends and relatives looking for somewhere safe to put their cash. Especially after the financial crisis.

No worries about bank runs with NS&I, or Financial Services Compensation Scheme limits, or your savings somehow getting muddled up in riskier lending. Just okay interest rates, the infinitesimal chance to win big with ERNIE, and a recommendation made in the same vein as nobody getting fired for buying IBM.

Also, faith in NS&I’s systems underwrites the Premium Bond draw.

There are already conspiracies about which Bonds win and who gets what prizes. NS&I can do without incompetence creeping into the mix, too.

Further reading:

  • A terse apology from National Savings & Investments – NS&I
  • NS&I boss replaced as savers left waiting for millions of pounds – BBC
  • What caused the missing NS&I savings, and what you should do – Guardian
  • Another take on the scandal and next steps if you’re affected – Which
  • NS&I will have to pay compensation in some cases, say ministers – This Is Money

Have a great weekend.

From Monevator

Commodities are working – Monevator

The natural yield model portfolio wheels are turning – Monevator [Members]

From the archive-ator: A plan to be financially independent in ten years – Monevator

News

OECD says UK will be hardest hit by Iran war, sees 4% inflation – CNBC

World faces ‘stark and deep recession’, says BlackRock boss – This Is Money

Temporary petrol shortages possible at some pumps, warns ASDA – Guardian

How Trump and the oil price move in sync [Charts]BBC

Reminder: the state pension age rises in April – Which

Buying UK housing most affordable since 2015 on price-to-earnings basis… – ONS

…as London house prices drop again… – City AM

…but rents are at an all-time high relative to incomes – Sky

Final candidates for seven new towns named – BBC

SpaceX’s mooted IPO valuation is in another orbit – Sherwood

Government defends landlord tax hikes as ‘fairer’ system – Property 118

FCA launches later life mortgage [a.k.a. equity release] study – Mortgage Strategy

Who ate all China’s stock market returns? [Paywall]FT

Products and services

Disclosure: Links to platforms may be affiliate links, where we may earn a commission. This article is not personal financial advice. When investing, your capital is at risk and you may get back less than invested. With commission-free brokers other fees may apply. See terms and fees. Past performance doesn’t guarantee future results.

The savings accounts that will pay you up to 5% – Which

How to swap houses for your holidays – Guardian

Don’t rely on AI to find you the best savings deal – Which

Get up to £3,000 cashback when you open or switch to an Interactive Investor SIPP. Terms and fees apply, affiliate link – Interactive Investor

HSBC, Barclays, Nationwide, and Halifax hike mortgage costs – Yahoo Finance

Five-year mortgages now cheaper than two-year fixes again – Mortgage Strategy

Fixed-rate mortgages go above 5.5%, but 4% trackers are available – This Is Money

Get up to £1,500 cashback when you transfer your cash and/or investments to Charles Stanley Direct through this affiliate link. Terms apply – Charles Stanley

Natwest switch offer: £150, or £250 for Premier account – Be Clever With Your Cash

What are passkeys and why should you use them for security? – Oblivious Investor

The best and worst family deals at major UK attractions – Be Clever With Your Cash

Loft-style apartments for sale, in pictures – Guardian

Comment and opinion

Could the triple-lock be scrapped, and should it be? – This Is Money

Index funds work – Money Changes Everything

Echoes of history: what the oil shock means for your money [Paywall]FT

Seven lessons from ‘enoughfluencers’ on how to live a simpler, happier life – Guardian

Yes you can beat the market by avoiding its worst days. But you won’t – Morningstar

Why are young people taking so many unwise financial risks? – Bloomberg Advisor Perspectives

Safe until crisis: what 300 years of wars reveals about government debt – CEPR

Your financial past isn’t true. Neither is your future – The Net Worthwhile Weekly

The quiet transformations that separate investors from stewards – Bogumil Baranowski

How to compare well – Mr Stingy

The woes of managing money for a friend or relative – Financial Samurai

Hendrik Bessembinder has updated his influential stock return study [Research]SSRN

Naughty corner: Active antics

The big problem with UK investment trusts – City AM

VCTs brace for record season after ‘bonkers’ tax relief cut – This Is Money

The reality of setting up as a solo investment advisor – Flyover Stocks

Ex-US markets look a good bet for value investors… – Verdad

…as Verdad’s founder Dan Rasmussen warns on private equity and more – Arena

In Elon Musk’s mind, SpaceX and Tesla have already merged – Sherwood

Tetra Pak: the shape of innovation – Quartr

Kindle book bargains

The End of Reality by Jonathan Taplin – £0.99 on Kindle

Boomerang by Michael Lewis – £0.99 on Kindle

Money Men by Dan McCrum – £0.99 on Kindle

Economica by Victoria Bateman – £0.99 on Kindle

Or pick up one of the all-time great investing classics – Monevator shop

Environmental factors

Britain sets new wind power generation record – RE News

Green energy enquiries surge as households fear price spike – This Is Money

Plug-in solar panels to become legal in the UK – Which

Evan Davis: heat pumps work for me – BBC

Earth’s climate increasingly out of balance – World Meteorological Organisation

The carbon burden of US companies – Klement on Investing

An unstoppable mushroom is tearing through North American forests – BBC

Robot overlord roundup

So long, SoraSpyglass

Human musicians are doomed – Klement on Investing

Inside China’s robotics revolution – Guardian

There will be no permanent underclass – Of Dollars and Data

Not at the dinner table

The world’s policeman is on the take – New York Times [h/t Abnormal Returns]

Treason in the futures market – Paul Krugman

There isn’t always a ‘long arc’ of morality – Noahpinion

Democracy watchdog finds Trump aiming for dictatorship – Guardian

There’s an information void at the heart of the Iran war – Bloomberg

The voter fraud fraud – The Bulwark

Off our beat

Cheap drones are reshaping the war in the sky – Reuters

Five years of lessons from running a bookstore – Ryan Holiday

“I escaped North Korea with my mum. But…”BBC

The clock in our genes – Aeon

Scientists identify a speech trait that foreshadows cognitive decline – Science Alert

The indirect – and sometimes surprising – benefits of vaccines – Stat

Google search tips and hacks – Card Catalog

And finally…

“Human beings have a remarkable ability to accept the abnormal and make it normal.”
– Andy Weir, Project Hail Mary

Like these links? Subscribe to get them every Saturday. Note this article includes affiliate links, such as from Amazon and Interactive Investor.

Post Comment

WIN $500 OF SHOPPING!

    This will close in 0 seconds