Entrepreneurship November 4, 2026 0 Comments

Before You Hand Over Cash for AI Search Optimization, Discover These 5 Game-Changing Secrets They Don’t Want You to Know

Ever wondered what it takes for your business to pop up the moment someone casually asks ChatGPT, “Hey, who do you trust around here?” Well, you’re not alone in that quest. AI search isn’t just a buzzword—it’s reshaping how customers find businesses, and small business owners like us are scrambling to decode the magic behind those digital recommendations. Here’s the kicker: the jargon—AEO, GEO, AI-optimization galore—can make your head spin faster than a spinning top on caffeine. But guess what? You might already be ticking some boxes without even knowing it. Forget the idea that traditional SEO is dead—it’s alive and kicking, and you don’t need to empty your pockets on shiny new marketing schemes just yet. Instead, lean in and let’s talk about five down-to-earth things you should check before splurging on AI search optimization. Ready to turn that laptop smile into real leads? Let’s dive in.

LEARN MORE

Small business owner smiling while working on a laptop

Want your business to show up when someone asks ChatGPT for a recommendation? Join the club!

AI search is quickly becoming a hot topic among small business owners. At networking events here in Maine, I’ve been hearing more and more questions about getting businesses recommended by ChatGPT, whether traditional SEO still matters, and what changes business owners should be making to their websites.

With terms like AEO (Answer Engine Optimization) and GEO (Generative Engine Optimization) popping up everywhere, it’s easy to feel like you’re falling behind.

The good news? You may already be doing some of the work that helps your business get discovered through AI search.

Traditional SEO isn’t dead, and you don’t necessarily need an expensive new marketing package to get started. Before opening your wallet, take a look at these five things.

1. Make sure your website answers real customer questions.

Think about the questions you answer every week. Chances are, some of them aren’t addressed anywhere on your website.

Let’s say you own a roofing company. Your website probably mentions roof repairs and replacements, but does it explain how a homeowner can tell which one they need?

Someone searching Google might type “roof repair near me.” Someone using ChatGPT might ask, “My roof is 20 years old and some of the shingles are curling. Should I repair it or replace it?”

See the difference?

People can use AI search to ask detailed questions about their problems before they’re ready to contact a business. If your website offers helpful answers, you’ve given both potential customers and search tools more information to work with.

Not sure where to start? Think about:

Questions customers ask before requesting an estimate.
Misconceptions you find yourself correcting.
Factors that affect pricing or project timelines.
Questions people ask when comparing two services.

You don’t need to publish a separate blog post for every question. Adding a few useful paragraphs to an existing service page may be a better place to start.

My recommendation: Write down five questions customers have asked you recently. Then check whether your website answers them.

2. Give readers something they can’t find on every other website.

Have you ever visited a business website and read something along the lines of “We provide exceptional service and quality solutions tailored to your needs”?

Sounds nice, but what does it actually tell you?

With AI making it easier than ever to generate website content, there’s no shortage of articles covering the same old topics. If your content could have been written about any business in your industry, you’re missing an opportunity.

Imagine you own an insulation company in Maine. You could publish an article titled “5 Benefits of Home Insulation.”

Or you could write about why some older Maine homes have cold bedrooms even after the attic has been insulated. Explain what you’ve found during actual inspections, what homeowners tend to overlook, and what you check before recommending additional work.

Which article would be more helpful to someone dealing with a freezing bedroom in January?

Your firsthand experience is something worth putting to work.

Include photos from actual projects. Explain why you recommended one solution over another. Share a common mistake you’ve seen customers make.

You don’t have to give away every trick of the trade, but sharing useful knowledge can go a long way toward building trust.

Remember: Your experience is something you can bring to your content that a generic AI-generated article can’t.

None of this guarantees your business will appear in an AI-generated answer. But original, specific information gives people a reason to visit your website and gives search tools useful material to discover.

3. Find out what other websites say about your business.

Your website isn’t the only place customers learn about your company, and it isn’t the only source AI search tools may use.

Depending on the platform and the question, information can come from business directories, reviews, industry websites, articles, and other public sources.

So what happens if your website lists one phone number, your Google Business Profile has another, and an old directory says you offer a service you stopped providing three years ago?

At the very least, you’re making things unnecessarily confusing for potential customers.

Start by checking your information in the places that matter most:

Google Business Profile: Are your hours, services, categories, and contact details accurate?
Industry directories: Are you listed under the right services and location?
Professional organizations: Does your chamber of commerce or industry association have an accurate member listing?
Social media: Do your public profiles clearly explain what you do and link to your website?

It’s also worth looking for legitimate opportunities to get your business mentioned on relevant websites.

Maybe you’ve participated in a community project, earned a professional certification, or partnered with another local business. Those are all things you could share.

Just don’t get carried away buying directory listings for the sake of backlinks. A handful of relevant, accurate listings can be more worthwhile than a long list of questionable ones.

4. Don’t overlook the SEO work your website already needs.

Before paying someone to optimize your website for AI search, find out whether they’ve checked how your website is performing in traditional search.

If Google can’t find your main service pages, why jump straight into a new AI search package?

Search engines still need to discover and understand your content. Important pages should be accessible, navigation should make sense, and your website should clearly explain what your business offers.

Before investing in another service, consider whether:

Your important pages can be found by search engines.
Each main service has a useful description.
Page titles accurately describe the content.
Related pages are linked together where appropriate.
Your contact information and service area are easy to find.

Some of these improvements may sound less exciting than “AI optimization,” but that doesn’t make them less important.

I’ve seen plenty of small business websites that could benefit from improving the content they already have.

If your main service page consists of two vague paragraphs and a contact button, why not start there?

A new blog post might be helpful down the road, but improving a page that potential customers are already visiting could be a better use of your marketing budget.

5. Ask what you’re actually paying for.

Here’s where I’d encourage business owners to ask a few extra questions.

There are tools that test whether your business appears in AI-generated answers. Some track mentions, citations, or an overall AI visibility score.

Those reports can provide useful information, but they don’t tell the whole story.

Let’s say an agency reports that your business appeared in 40% of the AI searches it tested.

Sounds promising, right?

Your business appeared in 40% of AI searches. Great. But 40% of what searches?

Were they questions your actual customers would ask? Did they include your location? Were they related to the services you want to sell?

And what happens after the report arrives?

Will the agency use that information to improve your website, research customer questions, and make meaningful changes? Or are you mostly paying to see how often your name appears in a set of test results?

There’s a difference between identifying an opportunity and doing something about it.

AI-generated answers can vary based on the question, location, available sources, and other factors. A business appearing in one test doesn’t mean it will be recommended to everyone.

I’d also want to know how the agency plans to measure results beyond AI mentions.

Google Search Console can help track search performance, and Google Analytics can provide information about website visits and actions. Neither offers a complete picture of every AI recommendation, but both can contribute to understanding what’s happening.

And don’t underestimate the value of simply asking new customers how they found you.

For most small businesses, I’d be more interested in receiving five qualified inquiries than appearing in dozens of AI-generated answers that never lead to a conversation.

So, is AI search optimization worth paying for?

It can be!

There’s real work involved in researching customer questions, improving website content, fixing technical problems, and making sure your business information is accurate across the web.

And let’s face it, if you’re running a small business, you probably have enough on your plate already.

Hiring someone to handle that work can make sense. Just be sure you understand what you’re getting.

If an agency is offering AI search optimization, ask what changes they’ll actually make and how those changes fit into your existing marketing strategy.

I’d be especially cautious of anyone promising a number-one ranking in ChatGPT. AI-generated recommendations aren’t fixed rankings, and nobody can guarantee your business will appear.

You don’t have to become an SEO expert to ask good questions about where your marketing dollars are going.

Takeaway

AI search is changing how people find information, but that doesn’t mean every small business needs to start from scratch.

Before investing in another marketing service, take a good look at your existing website. Are you answering the questions your customers ask? Are you sharing useful information based on your experience? Can people find accurate details about your business?

Start with the areas that need the most attention, and build from there.

The goal isn’t simply to get your business mentioned by ChatGPT. It’s to help the right customers find you, understand what you offer, and feel confident enough to get in touch.

Whether they discover you through Google, AI search, or good old-fashioned word of mouth, that’s what matters.

About the author

Salena Poussard is the owner of Good Light Marketing, a Maine-based digital marketing business helping small businesses with SEO, AI search optimization, social media, and email marketing. With over 10 years of digital marketing experience, she focuses on practical strategies and straightforward advice.