Is Your Hand Cream Habit Actually Harming Your Skin? Dermatologists Reveal the Shocking Truth!

Is Your Hand Cream Habit Actually Harming Your Skin? Dermatologists Reveal the Shocking Truth!

Confession time: I own an embarrassing stockpile of hand creams—30 to be exact. Yeah, I know, not the best move when I’m trying to streamline my skincare routine. But hey, as a beauty editor, testing the latest launches is kinda my jam. And let me tell you, hand cream isn’t just a winter fling; it’s a year-round must-have. You might not realize it, but our palms don’t have the oil-producing glands that keep skin naturally hydrated. Skip the hand cream, and you’re inviting dryness, itchiness, and cracked nails to the party. So, how much hand cream is too much? Should you reach for creams or lotions? When’s the best time to apply? I broke down all things hand cream with board-certified dermatologists so you can shop smart, save money, and keep those hands looking fab every day—without hoarding your own mini skincare store. Ready to upgrade your hand cream game? LEARN MORE

Estimated read time6 min read

I own an embarrassing number of hand creams. Ahem, it’s 30, which isn’t ideal since I’m looking to cut down on my skincare routine. But as our beauty editor, I get a thrill from trying the latest launches. My pricey skincare habit also means I can share the most effective skincare products worth your hard-earned money. If there’s one skincare product I can’t live without, it’s a hand cream. They aren’t just for during the winter—hand creams are a year-round necessity.

Our palms actually lack sebaceous glands that produce oil to keep them hydrated, says board-certified dermatologist Alexis Granite, MD. Skipping hand cream results in dry, tight, flaky, and itchy skin. It also causes cuticles and nails to become dry, Dr. Granite says.

They’re a daily necessity for hard-working hands, but there’s only so much hand cream your skin can soak up at a time. To help you navigate shopping like a pro and avoid ending up with 30 hand creams like me, I consulted dermatologists about all things hand creams. They answer everything from whether you can overuse hand cream to the differences between hand creams and lotions. The doctors also share how much hand cream we should apply, when to apply it, and more.

Hand Cream vs. Lotion: What is the Difference?

You’ve probably noticed that some brands offer hand lotions, while others sell hand creams. Both moisturize dry skin, but the difference lies in their oil-to-water ratio.

  • Hand creams contain more oil than water, making them richer, more hydrating, and better for very dry skin, says Dr. Granite. Their thicker formulations are helpful for very dry skin.
  • Hand lotions are more water-based and lightweight. They absorb quickly, making them helpful if you wash your hands often and need to get back to work right away, she says.

Board-certified dermatologists Serena Mraz, MD, and Blair Murphy-Rose, MD, prefer creams over lotions because they contain skin-replenishing and barrier-repairing lipids. While Dr. Granite alternates between the two types of moisturizers.

So which one should you choose?

Your environment can help determine which option is best for your needs. If you live in a humid climate like my home state of Florida, a lightweight lotion offers just the right amount of moisture. But in dry regions or when indoor heating is cranked up, humidity drops, and the skin loses more moisture. In that case, using a heavier cream may be necessary for ample hydration, says Dr. Granite.

Also consider how much jewelry you’re wearing. You may develop irritation if moisture becomes trapped underneath your rings, says Dr. Granite. Your safest bet is to remove the rings, apply hand cream, and let it soak in before putting them back on.

Ultimately, Dr. Granite says that consistency is the most important factor. Regardless of which formulation you opt for, any hydration is better than none. So pick an option that works for your needs and budget, and one you’ll actually use.

What are the best ingredients for hand creams?

It’s easy to get lost online when shopping for hand creams. Sephora has nearly 40, while Amazon’s offering features 50,000 results, with 20,000 options for $15 or less. But focusing on the ingredient label can help guide you. Here’s a quick hit list to keep in mind whenever you’re shopping for hand cream, according to Dr. Murphy-Rose.

  • Occlusives, including petrolatum (petroleum jelly), form a barrier on the skin’s surface to seal in moisture and prevent water loss.
  • Emollients, such as ceramides, dimethicone, and squalane, help soften and smooth the skin.
  • Humectants like glycerin, hyaluronic acid, aloe vera, and urea pull moisture to the skin. They’re less critical in colder, drier climates since there is less moisture to pull from the air.
  • Soothing ingredients, such as oat extract and bisabolol, can help calm irritation.

Can you use too much hand cream?

Good news: The short answer is no. All three dermatologists agree that you can’t really overapply hand cream and most people don’t use enough product. “It is virtually impossible to ‘overdose’ on hand cream,” says Dr. Mraz. Regular hand washing strips moisture throughout the day, so you don’t need to worry about over-hydrating, says Dr. Granite.

Using too much hand cream is more of a nuisance than anything else. When you apply more than a pea-to-dime-sized amount of hand cream, your hands might feel slippery, or it may not be soaking into your skin. You can simply wipe the excess off, share with a friend, or spread it up your arms, says Dr. Mraz.

When to Apply Hand Cream

Your hands are constantly exposed to the elements and harmful ultraviolet sun rays. Since you use your hands daily—showering, hand washing, and chores like laundry and dishes—they’re exposed to water, detergents, and irritants. Do you also take public transportation? Hand sanitizers can deplete your hands’ hydration, leaving them parched and flaky.

The solution: Dr. Mraz, Dr. Granite, and Dr. Murphy-Rose agree that we should apply hand cream several times daily. They advise applying hand cream after every wash, but at least once in the morning and before bed. Keep a jar on your nightstand so it’s convenient to apply.

What hand cream do dermatologists recommend?

Curious about which hand creams dermatologists actually use and suggest to their patients? Same! I asked the pros to share their no-fail recommendations, and these are the top picks.

Best Overlal

Wonder·Land Mini

Joonbyrd Wonder·Land Mini

Best for Mature Skin

Collagen Hand Cream

Seaweed Bath Co. Collagen Hand Cream

For Sensitive Skin

Moisturizing Cream

CeraVe Moisturizing Cream

Now 11% Off

Credit: JL

Best for Sunspots

Hand & Nail Cream

Beau Domaine Hand & Nail Cream
Credit: JL

For Cracked Skin

Healing Ointment

Aquaphor Healing Ointment

For Parched Hands

Advanced Repair Hand Cream

Eucerin Advanced Repair Hand Cream

Is hand cream only meant for hands?

With upcoming warm-weather travel plans at the top of mind, packaging space is limited. To help, I asked the dermatologists if we can also use hand cream on our bodies, feet, and even our faces when we’re in a pinch. Turns out, hand cream is multipurpose when you need it, but you probably shouldn’t make a habit of it.

“There is certainly no harm in using a hand cream all over the arms, legs, torso, neck, or face,” says Dr. Mraz. But because it’s thicker than lotions, it can cause breakouts on acne-prone skin. And its smaller container (usually 3 fl. oz or less) makes it harder to reapply on larger areas of the body.

FWIW, hand cream works as an excellent dupe for foot cream. Just ask Dr. Mraz, who applies hand cream to both her palms and feet. Thickened skin on the feet is common in summer months with bare feet, so exfoliating them and following up with a hand cream provides heavy moisture. To maximize hydration, slip on cotton gloves or socks after applying a rich hand cream to help it absorb more effectively, especially for those with eczema or very dry skin, says Dr. Granite.

The Bottom Line

You don’t need to purchase 30 hand creams to experience real results—your skin deserves daily hydration. The best hand cream or lotion is the one you’ll actually use and reapply. Pick a lotion if you live somewhere warm, reapply frequently, or don’t need intense moisture. Choose a heavy-duty cream if your hands need a beauty SOS, like if you’re dealing with chapped, dry, or flaky skin.

Meet the Experts

  • Alexis Granite, MD, is board-certified dermatologist licensed in the U.S. and U.K. She is the founder of the skincare line Joonbyrd.
  • Serena Mraz, MD, is a board-certified dermatologist practicing at Solano Dermatology Associates in California.
  • Blair Murphy-Rose, MD, is a board-certified dermatologist in New York City and Newport Beach, CA. She is also a clinical instructor of dermatology at Cornell Medical Center.
  • Nicole Ruth, DO, is a board-certified dermatologist practicing at Weiser Skin MD in New York.

Shop More of Our Favorite Products

Best Wrinkle Cream | Best At-Home Waxing Kit | Body Wash for Women | Best Moisturizer for Mature Women | Best At-Home Laser Hair Removal Devices | Best Epilator | Best Microcurrent Device | Best Lip Balm | Hair Wax Sticks | Best Strengthening Shampoos | Red Light Therapy For Hair Growth

Headshot of Nicole Saunders

Nicole Saunders is the beauty editor at Women’s Health and has nine years of experience researching, writing, and editing lifestyle content. She specializes in breaking down complicated topics, like red light therapy for hair growth and LED face masks, into easy-to-understand guides. Saunders takes great pride in heavily researching and testing featured beauty products, such as strengthening shampoos and body washes for dry skin on our site.   
Previously, she was the beauty editor at Best Products where she tested quite literally thousands of launches for her quarterly column and the Best New Beauty Awards package. She also launched the beauty and wellness coverage at NBC News and contributed to CNN, Cosmopolitan, Billboard, The Hollywood Reporter, and Harper’s BAZAAR.   
You can follow her on Instagram to stay in the loop on her product testing adventures.

Post Comment

WIN $500 OF SHOPPING!

    This will close in 0 seconds