Is This the Turning Point? The Surprising Housing Markets Where Sellers Are Losing Their Grip and Buyers Are Taking Control

In This Article

We know the narrative: The housing market is too expensive. That, however, appears to be changing.

Data from Parcl Labs shows where the ice is cracking. Sellers are beginning to blink, face reality, and cut prices. In doing so, they hope to gain a competitive edge in markets where listings are accumulating.

That’s great news for investors, who have grown frustrated by not being able to make the numbers work for flips or buy-and-hold deals, and for potential homeowners trying to get on the property ladder.

The three parcel maps—showing price changes, the balance between supply and demand, and where motivated sellers are—examine the changing market from different angles. Together, they reveal where seller pressure has started to translate into lower home prices.

One overriding fact becomes apparent: The U.S. housing market is not monolithic. It differs markedly depending on where you live. In parts of the Sunbelt, notably Florida and Texas, as well as the Mountain West, sellers might be willing to strike a deal as their leverage lessens. However, in parts of the Northeast and Midwest, the market remains tight, with sellers less willing to negotiate.

How the Data Works

For investors, the map Parcl Labs calls its Motivated Seller Index (MSI) is an invaluable barometer for gauging what kind of offer to make. It runs from 0 to 10 and is based mainly on sellers’ price-cutting behavior, namely, how frequently sellers reduce asking prices, how large the reductions are, and the speed at which sellers make them.

Scores between 5 and 7.5 indicate motivated sellers, while anything above 7.5 can be considered—if you excuse the unfortunate topicality for West Coast markets—fire-sale territory.

Viewed through a national lens, motivated sellers are clearly clustered around Texas, Florida, and the interior West, with Austin as one of the strongest examples. It has an MSI of 7.22, which puts it very close to the fire-selling threshold.

An alarming 53% of listings have seen a price cut, and one-third are new construction. That means builders and individual homeowners often compete for the same buyers as demand becomes more selective, creating a race to the bottom on price to lure would-be homeowners.

The pattern extends way beyond Austin into other parts of Texas. San Antonio has an MSI of 7.11 and price cuts on approximately 54% of its listings. Tampa is at 7.01 and Dallas at 6.98. Sellers are also motivated in Denver and Colorado Springs, which have MSIs of 6.84 and 6.81, respectively.

That doesn’t mean buyers should immediately head to those markets, as, irrespective of what you bid, the numbers still have to work. But buyers seem more likely to accept your offer—a notable change from the bidding wars of the pandemic-era market.

The contrasts between different parts of the country can be striking. Rochester, New York, is an area where sellers are displaying little wiggle room. Out of 3,448 listings, the MSI is just 2.25, classifying it as a neutral market. Price cuts are on only 16% of listings, which are roughly 1% higher in price than a year earlier.

The Supply-Demand Gap Helps Explain Why

Seller motivation tells us what sellers are doing. The Supply-Demand map helps explain why. It measures the difference between year-over-year (YOY) supply growth and YOY demand growth.

Parcl Labs defines supply as the total number of homes listed for sale and demand as completed sales. It compares both with the previous year, smooths the figures over three months, and measures the gap between the two. Green areas indicate markets where supply is growing faster than demand; red areas indicate markets where demand is growing faster than supply.

The geographic pattern is revealing. Much of the Northeast and parts of the Midwest appear red on the supply-demand map, meaning buyers compete for tight inventory and sellers gain an advantage even in high-cost markets.

Head West and South, however, and the picture starts to change as supply increases relative to demand in parts of Texas, Florida, Arizona, Utah, Colorado, and the Mountain West.

That changes the game for sellers as they contend with more listings. Many Sunbelt homes are brand new, and builders are incentivizing buyers with concessions and rate drops. New construction comprises 34% of Austin’s listings, 32% of San Antonio’s, and almost the same number in Dallas.

That matters for investors. Population growth, employment, and good schools and amenities can only carry us so far if new inventory comes to market faster than buyers can absorb it.

Where Seller Pressure Is Already Showing Up in Prices

The third map completes the picture by showing where seller leverage has moved the needle and begun to affect home values.

When tracking one-year price ranges, green areas on the map represent appreciation, and red areas represent declines. Markets where three signals overlap are particularly compelling: motivated sellers, supply outpacing demand, and falling prices. This is where the buy box starts flashing red.

Austin displays all these characteristics. Its MSI is 7.22, with over half of its listings having experienced a price cut; home prices are down 9.6% YOY and roughly 32% below their recorded peak, showing the full extent of its price reset.

Similar, though less extreme, is Colorado, with Denver prices down 7.3% over the last year and Colorado Springs down about 8.6%. Both markets have MSIs approaching 7, with price cuts on over 50% of listings.

In San Antonio, prices are down approximately 6.2% YOY, while Tampa has fallen about 4.5% and Dallas 3.2%. These numbers don’t scream housing crash; they indicate a market shifting to one where buyers now have the upper hand.

A map indicating motivated sellers does not necessarily correlate to falling prices. Some counties appear green on the price-change map despite weakening seller behavior. Elsewhere, the opposite is true: falling prices with particularly motivated sellers.

This divergence is a useful tool, suggesting that three metrics could capture three different stages of the market readjustment. Parcl Labs’ research tends to show that sellers might be the first to crack before appreciation slows—by seven to eight weeks.

For investors trying to identify turning markets, that lag would give them a strategic advantage over buyers looking for markets where prices have already fallen. However, many markets differ, and the data shows that the maps should be read in conjunction to signal an overall shift and long-term price declines.

What This Means for Buyers and Investors

The opportunity in this data is not simply to pinpoint the reddest county on the map. Falling prices are undoubtedly a strong sign that a market might be turning—but they could also indicate other issues, such as rising crime, taxes, and insurance costs.

Rising inventory might create bargains, but if the rate of increase is slower than the buyer would want, the market might remain competitive. Motivated sellers might also indicate something else is wrong with the market rather than simply a reality check on pricing.

However, viewed collectively, certain assumptions can be made: A high MSI, plus supply outpacing demand and falling prices, is a strong indication that prospective buyers will have negotiating leverage.

Conversely, a low MSI, with demand outpacing supply and rising house prices, indicates that sellers are still in the driving seat. Parcl Labs’ data offers an early-warning tool to signal key market shifts for investors, most notably that the urgency to transact has shifted from the buyer to the seller.

Interesting markets are those where all the signals haven’t lined up. For example, an increasing MSI has just started, or weakening supply/demand has not yet affected prices. These are where potential deals could lie.

The data is not a fail-safe, however; it is a helpful screening instrument. Due diligence on all the other factors (taxes, insurance, jobs, crime, development, schools, commuting distance, etc.) still needs to be undertaken before any offers are tabled.