The Shocking Percy Jackson Rankings That Goodreads Won’t Admit—Which Book Reigns Supreme?
So, Season 3 of the Disney+ smash hit Percy Jackson and the Olympians has just dropped—and I gotta ask: have you ever wondered which of Rick Riordan’s OG books really sets the gold standard? I’ve been rocking a Camp Half-Blood shirt for over 15 years (yeah, the dedication’s real), and as a hardcore fan who’s devoured both the page-turners and the TV adaptation, I’m diving deep to rank the five original Percy Jackson books that sparked this epic saga. Season 3 takes its cues from The Titan’s Curse, so buckle up to see where that one lands on my list—and hey, we’ll even check if Goodreads is on the same page. Ready for some mythological mayhem and honest fan feels? Let’s get into it! LEARN MORE
Season 3 of the hit Disney+ series Percy Jackson and the Olympians is out today, and to celebrate, I’m ranking the Percy Jackson books that started it all. Am I qualified? Not exactly, unless 15 years of loving the series and owning a Camp Half-Blood shirt count. I’m just a super fan of Rick Riordan’s books and the TV adaptation. Season 3 is based on The Titan’s Curse, so you’ll want to see where that one lands. Keep scrolling for my ranking of the five original Percy Jackson books, and see if Goodreads agree.
Honorable mention: ‘The Mark of Athena’ – Disney Hyperion

The Mark of Athena isn’t in the original series, it’s the third book in the follow-up series Heroes of Olympus, but since it’s my favorite Percy Jackson book and one of my favorite books of all time, I had to include it. The plot begins after demi-god Annabeth Chase arrives at Camp Jupiter and is reunited with her boyfriend, Percy Jackson. From there, our heroes jet off across the Atlantic Ocean to try and make it to ancient Greece to stop the evil earth goddess Gaea from rising. It’s funny, fun and has a cliffhanger no one will see coming.
What I love about this Percy Jackson book: Annabeth is one of my favorite book characters of all time, and here, we finally get to read from her point of view. We also get to see her tap into an inner strength we didn’t know she had and get to know her on a more personal level.
What Goodreads users are saying: “This book has me doing all sorts of things. Laughing, crying, flailing my arms like a sworn crazy person and leaving me exhausted from the range of emotions I felt reading this book. The story was so good, and I love how everything is unraveling.”
5. ‘Sea of Monsters’

The second book in the Percy Jackson and the Olympians series was published in 2006 and begins after Percy’s best friend Grover Underwood goes missing. Soon after, the magical barrier around Camp Half-Blood begins to fail, and the only way to fix it is to travel to the Sea of Monsters, where the deadly Cyclops Polyphemus guards the Golden Fleece. Desperate to do something, Percy, Annabeth, Clarisse La Rue and a cyclops named Tyson head out to sea—and nothing will prepare them for what they face.
What I love about this Percy Jackson book: Sea of Monsters is good, don’t get me wrong, but if I’m ranking which of the Percy Jackson books is my favorite, this one just doesn’t stand out to me. It did give us one of the best Percy and Annabeth scenes though—the siren scene—so it does get bonus points for that.
What Goodreads users are saying: “This is where the series truly begins to flex its mythological muscles and emotional depth. I have to say that this book was better than the first with amazing plot twists. The slow-burn tension between Percy and Annabeth is delicious. That moment when Percy holds Annabeth against the sirens? Pure chef’s kiss. I could feel the tenderness beneath all the chaos.”
4. ‘The Lighting Thief’

This was the book that started it all. It was published in 2005 and follows a 12-year-old kid named Percy after he learns that he’s a half-blood, or demigod. Soon he’s whisked away to the magical Camp Half-Blood, where he learns that Zeus’s master bolt has been stolen and that he’s the prime suspect. In order to prove his innocence, Percy and his new friends, Annabeth and Grover, venture across the country to find the bolt and return it to Mount Olympus—before it’s too late.
What I love about this Percy Jackson book: The Lightning Thief will always hold a special place in my heart—it’s one of the books that got me into reading, and I’ll always love it. But compared to some of the other books in the series, the plot just isn’t as page-turning. I still love it though, and recommend that everyone read it at some point in their lives.
What Goodreads users are saying: “This book is amazing. My only regret is that I didn’t have it when I was 12 years old because I would have read this until it was falling apart in my hands. This is a fast-paced exciting fantasy story full of friendships, Greek mythology, magic, mystery, bad guys and girls and constant adventure.”
3. ‘The Last Olympian’

Published in 2009, this book is the last in the original series. The terrifying Lord Kronos is back, possessing Luke Castellan’s body. His mission? End the Greek gods and rule the world. The only person who can stop him is Percy, but he cannot do it alone. He will need the help of his friends Annabeth, Grover, Tyson, Clarisse and Nico di Angelo, as well as the help of his teachers and the gods. But when friends turn into foes and foes turn out to be friends, Percy begins questioning what he’s really fighting for. It’s a thrilling conclusion to an amazing series.
What I love about this Percy Jackson book: The Last Olympian had it all: romance, danger, twists, turns and even a bit of an ambiguous ending. Even so, when push comes to shove, it has to be placed at three because, in my opinion, the two books that came before it were just a little bit better.
What Goodreads users are saying: “Easily my favorite book in the series! It wrapped up this series perfectly and gave hints to what would happen in the Heroes of Olympus series! I’m definitely a little in love with Percy now and have a total girl crush on Annabeth and those last couple of pages killed me (in a good way). I’m so glad I finished this series and I can’t wait to start the Heroes of Olympus next year!”
2. ‘The Titan’s Curse’

Book three in the series was published in 2007 and serves as inspiration for Season 3 of the show. After a rescue mission goes wrong, both Annabeth is winds up being held captive by Kronos. Soon after, the Goddess Artemis goes missing as well. Percy, devastated by the loss of his friend, decides to travel across the country to find them both. Grover, Bianca di Angelo, Zoë Nightshade and Thalia Grace go with him. Shortly after their journey, enemies show up, and soon it becomes clear that not everyone is going to make it out alive.
What I love about this Percy Jackson book: The book is placed at number two simply because of how much Percy yearns for Annabeth the whole time. They are one of my favorite book couples ever, and here readers can really see what makes them so special.
What Goodreads users are saying: “I have yet to be disappointed in this series. A real rarity in a fantasy series in general. It never fails to impress me how the author can intricately put everything into these books. I never feel bored and I love the view he takes on different mythology stories. One of my biggest enjoyments is seeing different American landmarks mentioned in the story, and seeing their odd connection to the Greek myths.”
1. ‘The Battle of the Labyrinth’

Coming in at number one is the fourth book in the series, which was published in 2008. Kronos is getting closer and closer to resurrecting, and Camp Half-Blood is growing more and more vulnerable by the minute. To protect it, Percy, Grover, Annabeth and Tyson venture into the deadly Labyrinth, where they will face threats they couldn’t even begin to imagine. It’s thrilling, fun and filled with danger and heart.
What I love about this Percy Jackson book: Simply put, this book is amazing. The characters introduced to us in the labyrinth are intriguing, and the relationship between Percy and Annabeth reaches a whole new level that I loved.
What Goodreads users are saying: “This one is… just wow! I don’t know how this could get any better. The Battle of the Labyrinth blows the first three books out of the water. Though I am yet to read the final one, I think it’ll be harder to beat this one out of my-favorite-of-the-series spot. What an adventure.”
Ready for more? Subscribe to our YouTube channel for video podcasts, health tips and uplifting stories designed for women 40, 50, 60 and beyond.



Post Comment