Unlocking Airline Secrets: Are You Really Getting What You Pay for in ‘Basic’ First and Business-Class Fares?

Unlocking Airline Secrets: Are You Really Getting What You Pay for in 'Basic' First and Business-Class Fares?

Remember when “basic” tickets meant the last row in economy with your knees kissing the seat in front? Well, fasten your seatbelt — those days are flying out the window. United took the plunge first, rolling out “basic” fares not only in coach but stepping boldly up front. Delta followed suit, and JetBlue’s not far behind, prepping to expand these unbundled, budget-conscious tickets into first-class cabins. The twist? You might snag a business-class seat but lose the swanky lounge access or choice seating that once came standard with the higher price. Are we witnessing more choice—or a clever cloak-and-dagger price hike? As airlines slice and dice their fare structures, it’s worth asking: Are you really flying basic business, or just paying more for less? Buckle up and dive into the world where “basic” means premium with a catch. LEARN MORE

United did it first. Delta followed. And then came JetBlue.

Suddenly, everywhere travelers look, new types of “basic” tickets are popping up. And we’re not just talking about the cheapest, bare-bones fares in coach, which have been around for years.

We’re talking about the growing number of U.S. carriers that now offer “unbundled” tickets even for passengers sitting at the front of the plane.

Booking a United Airlines Polaris suite? The lowest price you see may be a “basic” business fare — and if you buy it, you can’t enter the airline’s swanky Polaris Lounge.

Delta Air Lines has a similar policy for its lowest business fares: No Delta One Lounge access is included.

SEAN CUDAHY/THE POINTS GUY

On both airlines, passengers booking those skinny premium fares can’t pick their seat or make itinerary changes.

JetBlue plans to roll out similarly stripped-down fares when it launches its new domestic first-class cabin later this year.

More choice or higher prices?

Unbundled fares are nothing new.

U.S. airlines have been selling basic economy fares widely for close to a decade.

Historically, these tickets have offered customers a trade-off: Book the lowest price point but stomach some restrictions.

Daily Newsletter

Reward your inbox with the TPG Daily newsletter

Join over 700,000 readers for breaking news, in-depth guides and exclusive deals from TPG’s experts

By signing up, you will receive newsletters and promotional content and agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy. You may unsubscribe at any time.

But lately, that trade-off has even crept to the front of the plane, with new choices like:

  • Economy or basic economy?
  • Business class or basic business class?
  • Premium economy or basic premium economy?
  • First class or domestic first class?

Plus, “basic” tickets have even made their way to some carriers’ award bookings.

More options vs. higher fares

Airlines argue these growing fare options offer consumers more options to pick from.

“It’s all about giving people more choice, more pricing options, and more products and services in every cabin,” Delta’s former president, Glen Hauenstein, said of the concept last year.

Delta One seating
Delta One cabin on the wide-body Airbus A350-900. SEAN CUDAHY/THE POINTS GUY

But industry analysts fear these new “basic” tickets often serve as a quiet price increase.

“It is an indirect fare hike,” Henry Harteveldt, president and founder of Atmosphere Research Group, told TPG. “The customer ends up paying more for the standard business class experience and benefits than they would have before.”

Which airlines sell ‘basic business’ and unbundled premium fares?

Here’s a rundown of which airlines are selling basic fares — and in which cabins.

Seating product American Airlines Delta Air Lines United Airlines Southwest Airlines Alaska Airlines JetBlue

√

√

√

√

√

√

Economy award tickets

X

√

X

√

X

√

Domestic first-class

X

√

√

N/A

X

√ (soon)

Premium economy

X

√

√

N/A

N/A

N/A

Business class

X

√

√

N/A

X

X

More from TPG:

Which airline is next?

So far, Delta, United and JetBlue have led the way on rolling “basic” fares beyond coach.

It’s worth watching whether others follow. After all, in the airline industry, carriers often match their rivals’ policies.

Harteveldt argues there’s now an opening for a major airline to curry favor with customers and duck this latest trend — one that, to some consumers, can feel like being nickel-and-dimed when flying on a pricey premium economy or business-class ticket.

“I even wonder if this doesn’t create an opportunity for airlines that aren’t yet selling basic business,” he said, offering up the line airlines could use: “‘We don’t charge you extra to get the things you have always enjoyed.'”

Interestingly, Alaska Airlines said last week that it would skip out on the “basic business” trend — at least for now.

That leaves American Airlines as the biggest holdout, at this point.

SEAN CUDAHY/THE POINTS GUY

Tips for booking in the world of ‘basic’ fares

As basic fares spread to more cabins on the planes, here are a few helpful hints to know as you book.

Know what you’re buying

Look closely at the fine print of your purchase before booking. Whether it’s a seat in the last row of economy or the front row of first class, there’s a chance it could come with a host of pesky restrictions.

Read the fare rules, and keep an eye out for labels like “base” or “basic” — that’s what airlines typically call these unbundled tickets.

Weigh the price and perks

Weigh the price, the perks and what’s important to you.

If simply getting a lie-flat seat for the cheapest price possible is most important to you, basic business might be an acceptable option.

But for other flyers, losing access to key premium benefits — like lounge access — may be a deal-breaker in booking one of these restrictive fares.

United Polaris Lounge at San Francisco International Airport (SFO). SEAN CUDAHY/THE POINTS GUY

Also, be sure your plans are set in stone before locking in one of these fares: You typically can’t make changes to basic fares in any cabin, and the airline may charge a fee if you later have to cancel.

Be especially careful with basic premium economy

Some travelers might be able to stomach basic fares in business class, where they’re guaranteed a lie-flat seat.

But in premium economy, losing seat selection has a real downside: You could get stuck in a middle seat.

Premium Plus on a United Airlines Boeing 787-9 Elevated Dreamliner. SEAN CUDAHY/THE POINTS GUY

Don’t forget about the loyalty tradeoffs

Basic fares typically earn fewer miles and elite credit than standard tickets. That’s an important consideration if you’re chasing status, or if you care about earning miles on your flight.

Plus, some premium basic tickets bar you from other loyalty perks, like upgrades, even if you’re flying up front.

For instance, travelers who book United’s “Polaris Base” fare on its most premium planes aren’t eligible to upgrade into the carrier’s luxe Polaris Studio suites.

Polaris Studios on United Airlines’ new Boeing 787-9 “Elevated” Dreamliner. SEAN CUDAHY/THE POINTS GUY

Think twice about booking a basic economy award

Three of the six largest U.S. airlines will now “sell” you basic economy tickets even when you’re booking with miles: Delta, Southwest and JetBlue.

Tread carefully: Those fares come with the same restrictions as basic fares booked with cash.

No U.S. airline currently offers basic awards in their premium cabins.

Related reading:

Post Comment

WIN $500 OF SHOPPING!

    This will close in 0 seconds